CMSC 304: Ethical and Social Issues in Information Technology (FINAL)
Course Schedule -- Spring 2014

Last revised 2014-04-25 // Subject to change.

Group Peer Evaluation Forms

#

Date

Topic

Reading

Handouts

Assignment Due







1

1/28

Course Overview & Team Selection

None



2

1/30

Topics Selection


None
Topic Selection Guidance (distributed in class)

Assignment 1

Writing Guidance


3

2/4

Ethical Frameworks

Cheng: "It's Time To Raise My Hand"

Tevani, Ch2 (in BlackBoard)

FYI...SCU: A Framework for Thinking Ethically



4

2/6

Legal & Professional Frameworks

Berzai: How Ethical Theories Apply to IT Professionals



 


2/11

Analysis Framework

None --  In-Class Workshop

Analysis Framework
In-class case

Assignment 1
Topic Readings


6

2/13

Computing History &

The Ethical Considerations of ICTs




7

2/18

Adoption of Disruptive Technology

Cortado:  Adoptions of Disruptive Technologies That Worked and Others That Did Not (PDF)

Economist: The shock of the new

McKinsey Report: Disruptive technologies: Advances that will transform life, business, and the global economy (PDF) - it's long, so feel free to skim!

How Technology Evolves

Wired: The Day Napster Died

Gartner: Top 10 Disruptive Trends for 2014

Supreme Court to review Aereo v. ABC copyright case

Commentary: The Ethics Of Torrents

3D Printers Create a New World of Possibility and Controversy
Ethical Analysis #1


8

2/20

Creativity & Maker Culture

The Maker Movement Manifesto: A conversation with Mark Hatch on a creative revolution

The Tension Between Innovation and Ethics

Economist: More than just digital quilting

P2P Foundation:  Maker Movement

Chris Anderson: Today’s ‘Maker Movement’ Is The New Industrial Revolution (Video)

Coders’ Rights Project Reverse Engineering FAQ

Guardian: The internet has created a new industrial revolution


9

2/25

Patents, Copyrights, & Fair Use

NOLO: The 'Fair Use' Rule: When Use of Copyrighted Material is Acceptable

Wren: Theory and reality for software patents: good in concept, not so good in practice (PDF)

Crichton: Patenting Life (and/or) CNN: Court: Human genes cannot be patented

Grahm: Liability of reverse engineering

News.Com  Amazon recalls (and embodies) Orwell's '1984'

EFF: Celebrating Fair Use for Copyright Week

Steele: The NFL Flexes its Copyright Muscle

(FYI: Stanford Summaries of Fair Use Cases)


10

2/27

Writing Workshop

ťNone

Writing Workshop Guidelines

DRAFT Ethical Analysis #1 (3 hardcopies)

11

3/4

'Ownership' Concepts in the Digital Age

File Sharing: A debate

Stallman: The Right to Read

Doctorow: What happens with digital rights management in the real world?

Guardian: Do you own your digital content?

Newitz: Dangerous Terms: A User's Guide to EULAs

Techdirt: How The Copyright Industry Made Your Computer Less Safe

Wired: Supreme Court OKs $222K Verdict for Sharing 24 Songs

Microsoft: Xbox 360 Digital Rights Management FAQ (Just an FYI)

Network World:  Jailed for jailbreaking

FINAL Ethical Analysis #1

12

3/6

Torrents & Influencing Global Information Flows


RT: BitTorrent ethics: Punishing piracy or criminalizing sharing?

EFF: Packet Forgery By ISPs: A Report on the Comcast Affair

Sherman: Deleted "Sensitive" Web Sites Still Available via Google

The Streisand Effect.  (Yes, I am using Wikipedia as a source, but it's the best one out there for this particular item.)

Ingrahm: News as a process: How journalism works in the age of Twitter

Penenberg: Bitcoins, Wikileaks, 3D printers, PGP and the gov’s battle against information

McCullagh: Security warning draws DMCA threat

FYI: Good Torrent News Resource: TorrentFreak

FYI: We Fight Censorship (the site & the article)

FYI: Should Internet Service Providers Fear Peer-Assisted Content Distribution? (PDF)

Midterm Review Guide
(handed out in class only)


13

3/11

Minors' Rights & Use of Technology

 
WaPo: Is technology sapping children’s creativity?

Howley: Children and Smartphones: What’s the Right Age?

PrivacyRights: Children's Safety on the Internet

AdWeek: Facebook Parents Object to Use of Teens' Images in Ads

ALA: Minors and Internet Interactivity: An Interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights

KQED: What Teens Feel About Privacy and Social Media

Saritzky: Online Privacy and “Generation C”: The Rights and Responsibilities Related to Children’s Use of the Internet

EFF: Are You A Teenager Who Reads News Online? According to the Justice Department, You May Be a Criminal  (this ties back to the need to reform the CFAA)

Skim: FTC: Complying with COPPA

Examiner: Supreme Court upholds video game rights

NBC: California law allows kids to erase Internet mistakes
Ethical Analysis #2

14

3/13

Midterm

Postponed Due to Campus Closure





!! Spring Break !!

(3/18 & 3/20)

None



15

3/25


Gaming & Internet addiction

Grant, et.al: Introduction to Behavioral Addictions

Psychology Today: Are Video Games Addictive?

CTV: South Korea considers measures to tackle online gaming addiction

Nextweb: A quiet killer: Why video games are so addictive

Wired UK: Flappy Bird creator pulled game over addiction concerns

Atlantic: Exploiting the Neuroscience of Internet Addiction

Griffiths: Does Internet and computer" addiction" exist? Some case study evidence (PDF)

Psychology Today: Internet Porn Addiction – Why Is Free Porn So Irresistible?

Salon: Internet addiction is just the next evolutionary step

Sample Professional  Ethics Codes

16

3/27

Midterm, Take 2


None



17

4/1

Sexism & Racism, & Violence in Video Games Kotaku: What It's Like To Be A Woman Making Video Games

Salon: Video games’ race problem goes all the way to the top

Professor Nakamura Discusses Discriminatory Behavior in Video Games

Tillack: A critique of the morality of violent video games

Consalvo: Confronting toxic gamer culture: A challenge for feminist game studies scholars

Kotaku: How Not To Address Homosexuality In Gaming

Extra Credits: True Female Characters (YouTube)


DRAFT Ethical Analysis 2

18

4/3

Autonomous Systems
 (Drones, self-driving cars, AI, etc.)

Anderson & Waxman: Law and Ethics for Robot Soldiers

Freitas: The Legal Rights of Robots

Bostrom: Ethical Issues in Advanced Artificial Intelligence

Arkin: Ethical Behavior in Lethal Autonomous Systems

Lin: The Ethics of Autonomous Cars

Anderson: Legal Infrastructure For Driverless Cars, And Comparisons Between The Law And Ethics Of Self-Driving Cars And Autonomous Weapon Systems

EPSRC: Principles of robotics - Regulating robots in the real world (Skim)

Bryson & Kyme: Just an Artifact: Why Machines are Perceived as Moral Agents (PDF)
Final Paper Guidance







In-class Group Deliverable

19

4/8

Censorship & Freedom of Expression

BBC: Porn filters block sex education websites 

NYT: Google’s Gatekeepers

Gallagher: French president promises law to make viewing “hate sites” an offense

Nishihata, Deibert, & Senft: Not By Technical Means Alone: The Multidisciplinary Challenge of Studying Information Controls (PDF)

EFF: A Short Guide to the Internet’s Biggest Enemies

Fisher: Freedom of Expression on the Internet

Guardian: Turkey Twitter users flout Erdogan ban on micro-blogging site
and then WaPo: Turkey strengthens Twitter ban, institutes IP level block

FYI: CA Court Holds That French Order Violates Yahoo!’s First Amendment Right To Offer Nazi Materials for Sale  (note the conflict between French laws and America's Constitutional Protections...interesting!)




FINAL Ethical Analysis 2





In-class Group Deliverable

20

4/10

Privacy vs. Anonymity

Morozov: The Real Privacy Problem

Tucker: Has Big Data Made Anonymity Impossible?

PIA: How Does Privacy Differ From Anonymity, And Why Are Both Important?

CNet: Internet privacy in an age of surveillance

WaPo: We need a new jurisprudence of anonymity

Gizmodo: Los Angeles Cops Argue All Cars in L.A. Are Under Investigation

(Skim) Pew: Anonymity, Privacy, and Security Online Survey Results (2013)

Tene & Polonetsky: Privacy in the Age of Big Data








In-class Group Deliverable

21

4/15

Surveillance (good & bad sources/uses/effects)

Volokh: The Benefits of Surveillance  (note, from 2002!)

SDMag: Video Surveillance Cameras: The Good, the Bad, and the Hype and Lessons from Boston

Fernback: In Context: Digital Surveillance, Ethics, and PRISM

Schneier: The Trajectories of Government and Corporate Surveillance

Schneier: Technologies of Surveillance

The Nation: It's Time for a 21st Century Debate on Privacy and Surveillance

FYI: Richards @ Harvard Law Review:  The Dangers of Surveillance

FYI: IEP:  Surveillance Ethics



Final Paper Topic Paragraph



In-class Group Deliverable

22

4/17

Flashpoints: SOPA, PIPA, CISPA and their effects on Internet use, security, & stability

ZDNet: What is CISPA, and what does it mean for you? FAQ

CNET: How SOPA would affect you: FAQ

Adelmann: CISPA is Big Brother’s Friend

OpenDNS: SOPA will be 'extremely disruptive' to the Internet

Post: SOPA and the Future of Internet Governance

Skim: EFF: How PIPA and SOPA Violate White House Principles Supporting Free Speech and Innovation

FYI: EFF's Open Letter from Academics, Experts, & Engineers on CISPA (disclosure: I signed this)

FYI: News.Com:  Hollywood hacking bill hits House







In-class Group Deliverable

23

4/22

Public Whistleblowing in the Internet Age


Housh: The Vacuum That Created Anonymous, Wikileaks, and the Whistleblower Explosion

FCW: Rethinking whistleblowing in the digital age

boyd: Whistleblowing Is the New Civil Disobedience

Hart: Good Leaks and Bad Leaks

Economist: The perils of whistleblowing  (video)

DOD: Clapper: Snowden Caused ‘Massive, Historic’ Security Damage

Guardian:  Who should judge whether Snowden's leaked secrets are too sensitive to report?

FYI: Hayase: The whistleblowers at the frontier of digital liberation





In-class Group Deliverable

24

4/24

Future Scenario Workshop


None




In-class Group Deliverable (possibly for posterity & fame!)



25

4/29


Student Work Day


Extended office hours from 1 - 3:30PM for anyone needing or wanting assistance or guidance on their final papers or presentations

Presentation Schedule
 (via email)

Presentation Guidance

Presentation Grading

Presentation Tips


26

5/1

Presentations

None

Presentation Feedback Form

28

5/6

Presentations, (con't)

None

Presentation Feedback Form

29

5/8

Presentations,  (con't)

None
Group Peer Evaluations Form

Presentation Feedback Form

29

5/13


Presentations, (con't)

None

FINAL Paper

Presentation Feedback Form

30

5/20

Presentations, (con't)
This is during final exam week.

None


Group Peer Evaluation Forms

Presentation Feedback Form